November verse 8, 2024, and Standing Together

Last week I went to a meeting where two members of Standing Together spoke. Standing Together is a grassroots movement of Jews and Palestinians in Israel working for peace, equality, and social and climate justice (website here).

At the meeting, organised by the recently formed Sydney Friends of Standing together, Shahd Bishara and Nadav Shofet gave personal accounts of their involvement in the movement. Shahd Bishara, a Palestinian Israeli medical practitioner, said, among other things:

The liberation of Palestine is inextricably intertwined with the security of Israelis. Two peoples both live in the land that both call our homeland. We need to fight for freedom of Palestinians and the safety of the Israeli Jews.

Nadav Shofet, an Israeli Jew, spoke of the absence of an alternative narrative to the genocidal one of perpetual war put forward by the Israeli right. Standing Together aims to fill that vacuum with a narrative that includes hope.

There’s much more to say. Standing Together has been attacked from the right in the USA and Europe, and from the left in Australia. My comments section isn’t open for that debate. The ABC covered the visit here.

Without wanting to in any way trivialise the struggle that was the subject of the meeting, I kept my ears open for an iambic tetrameter that could kick off an Onegin stanza. I got one. Nadav was referring to the narrative vacuum when he used the phrase, ‘In this environment of silence’. I have taken it somewhere else.

(The Emerging Artist says I should give links to W. B. Yeats, ‘Long-Legged Fly’ and Hopkins, ‘The Habit of Perfection’. Sadly I don’t remember the name of the Italian poet who inspired my last line.)

Verse 8: In this environment of silence

In this environment of silence
minds can move like Yeats’s fly
upon the stream, or can with violence
leave democracy to die.
Silence sings if it’s elected.
Silenced hearts by fear inflected
can’t or will not have their say –
stony, look the other way.
Silence thrives when life's unruly –
words as weapons, words as toys,
words as endless streaming noise
leave no room for words that truly
come from hearts that seek to heal
whose uvulas are made of steel.

11 responses to “November verse 8, 2024, and Standing Together

  1. love this one! xxx

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you, Jonathan. I’m sending the link to Standing Together contacts and also to a chat group for international supporters of the movement.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I love this, it’s inspired.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Wonderful place you took the poem, Jonathan! I have to say you should probably also give credit to Tom Tom Club’s “Wordy Rappinghood”. 😉😁
    “Words in papers, words in books
    Words on TV, words for crooks
    Words of comfort, words of peace
    Words to make the fighting cease”

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Th Lg f Ntns Plstn Mndt csd t xst n 1948. Pst th Jn 1967 Jrdn’s llglly szd (ccrdng t th N rsltn n 1950) Wst Bnk – lk Plstn csd t xst. Gt yr fcts strght.

    Like

    • Hi mosckerr. As I said in the post, my comments section isn’t open for the political debate. I’ve taken the traditional step of disemboweling your comment. People who really want to will still be able to read it

      Liked by 1 person

What do you think?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.